William Taylor Hotel
Art by: Chris Hytha
Story by: Mark Houser
It seemed like a good idea at the time, combining four city Methodist Episcopal congregations into one new church with an attached hotel whose patrons would pay off its construction debt. Rev. Walter Sherman persuaded his flock, at any rate. They named the hostelry after a missionary who established their faith's first congregation in San Francisco.
Worshipers filled the 1,500-seat sanctuary for its first service on Easter Sunday in 1930 to hear Sherman's sermon. But financial problems swiftly arose, leading to foreclosure. Other hoteliers entered the picture, relaunching as the Empire Hotel and converting the upper floor to a cocktail lounge. Their efforts also foundered, so they sold it to the federal government to billet draftees during World War II. The church's gothic vaults were later concealed with a drop ceiling and the space became an IRS office.
The worship space is now unused, but the building has been a dormitory for students at the nearby law school since 1981. Originally named after its founder, Serranus Hastings, the first chief justice of the California Supreme Court, the institution recently changed its name after historians uncovered how Hastings backed a bloody campaign by Mendocino County settlers against the resident Yuki people.